Disturbing questions

I've been thinking about the faculty member's power in the classroom. In spending time with some colleagues, I've been wondering how much of their teaching career is about that power over students rather than love of discipline, service to the community, career advancement, or something else.

A related question, how much can we expect our students to "confess" their experience?

I ask this because I sat in a session in a conference recently in which the presenter described an exercise they (gender unidentified here) ask students in the class to divide themselves in groups by subcultures. After that, they each have to sit in front of the class (in the group) and answer the question "What is hard for you as a member of your subculture about living in this country?" And they each must talk for two minutes on this.

Obviously, this instructor has an agenda.

I am appalled by this exercise. It seems a blatant use of the instructor's power. What if a student does not want to says what's hard? What if they don't think anything is hard? What if one group of students says their lives are harder than another group? What if a student is a member of two or three subcultures? What if their revelations just exacerbate stereotypes?

Thoughts?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Reflecting on Reflection in Learning

Reflection is the subject of my next couple of presentations, so here are my recent jottings. Hopefully a reader can make some sense of them;however, the whole point of this post is that reflection can follow a structure but will not necessarily create a structured record. The reflection record will need to be reshaped to be palatable for a "judge" or "critic" or "instructor." Reflection tends to be framed negatively. If we dig too deep we will only find bad stuff; if we reflect on teaching practice, we will focus on what failed rather than succeeded. Why? Assessment focuses on finding the nonlearners and changing to get more learners, but it ignores that most of the students did learn, so why were there successes? Leads to burnout. Boud & Walker’s idea of validation not well developed but relevant. It is most close to critical thinking—testing it against other knowledge, theories, internal consistency, other data (other learner’s data) Ref...
Read more

Calling all College Instructors

I had an interesting experience last semester. In a lecture on perception, I mentioned (because I had been reading so) that people with autism (my brother has it) do not perceive less than others, but they perceive more and that their behaviors are to block out or filter or deal with the overload. One boy in the back of the room said, "I know that's true because I'm autistic and .... " That's one of those "moments of truth." I often do not handle them well, but this one I did. Since the young man had not done anything that indicated autism to me (other than being nerdy), after he talked about himself I said, "Do you have Asperger's?" to which he said, "Yes, and ADD." Another young man in the class was giving me signals that he was in the same boat. There is something ironic and yet appropriate about this incident--only a student with Asperger's or Austism Spectrum Disorder would just announce it so boldly in class. ...
Read more

First Generation Students: Be aware

 I confess to not having blogged here for quite a while.  I will be in the future--I'm doing some relevant writing. My current research interest is gratitude, in general, in communication, in spiritual development, and in higher education. Although not quite linked to that, this article is thoughtful and reminds us of "the secret life of college students." https://diverseeducation.com/article/138698/?utm_campaign=DIV1902%20DAILY%20NEWSLETTER%20FEB15&utm_medium=email&utm_source=Eloqua
Read more